Skip to main content
Question Protected by CommunityBot
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackSkeptic/status/430876811275538432
The battery tag seems like a natural fit and helps bundle this with other battery-related questions. If it is attempting to be eliminated, please comment to that effect if you re-edit to remove the tag again.
Link
Hendy
  • 21.8k
  • 18
  • 119
  • 179
edited tags; edited tags
Link
Sklivvz
  • 78.9k
  • 29
  • 324
  • 429
Source Link
Hendy
  • 21.8k
  • 18
  • 119
  • 179

Can the health of an alkaline battery be determined by bouncing it?

I was just sent a YouTube video, which appears to demonstrate that one can determine the "health" of a battery (current voltage, useful lifetime remaining, etc.) by bouncing it on a level surface.

  • A new[ish] battery will not bounce, and tend to stay standing up.
  • A drained battery will bounce and tend to fall over.

The comments are wrought with typical subjective banter, such as "This is the greatest new piece of knowledge ever," and, "This is definitely a hoax," which leads me to believe it could be a good candidate for Skeptics.SE.

As far as other sources of the claim, there's a post on Straight Dope where members attempt to both reproduce the test (one appears to have done so successfully) as well as determine the mechanism by which it occurs.

Is the test more than a YouTube video hoax, and, if so, is there an explanation for the mechanism that allows it to work as a test for battery health?


In terms of assessing the term "health," please use typical measures of remaining battery lifetime. This could be the voltage at the present moment vs. the starting voltage, or some means of calculating the remaining capacity (mAh). I simply mean to suggest answering in a way that's both quantifiable and relevant to the mechanism of alkaline battery electricity output.