Skip to main content
Mad Scientist's user avatar
Mad Scientist's user avatar
Mad Scientist's user avatar
Mad Scientist
Moderator
  • Member for 13 years, 9 months
  • Last seen this week
  • nowhere
comment
Do reports from the UK show that Covid-19 vaccines had a higher mortality rate among children than the Covid Virus in 2021?
@AaarghZombies it's about exactly the same table that details the deaths by vaccination status and age from the UK.
awarded
comment
Did Elon Musk pay more in taxes than every politician in the world combined?
There are some important caveats here, the claim says that he paid more this year, and it compares only to politicians. Musk bought Twitter this year and as far as I understand he sold a significant amount of Tesla stocks for this. So this year is probably an outlier for Musk in terms of taxes.
revised
Is gonorrhea "on the brink of becoming untreatable"?
the comment about hypothetical vaccines is entirely unnecessary, and also entirely unreferenced.
Loading…
awarded
comment
Are roundabouts actually statistically safer than traditional traffic patterns?
@Simone Every driver in Germany has at least 12 * 45 minutes of driving instruction by a professional driving instructor (this is the legal minimum, the typical time is probably double that) and has to pass a practical driving test (which is not entirely trivial to pass). So the minimum level of driving lessons is much higher in Germany than in the US as far as I understand the US system.
awarded
awarded
comment
Has there been a 1101% increase in excess deaths among children aged 0-14 across Europe in 2022?
@Fizz The claim is about excess mortality, the graph shows total mortality. So if I understand it correctly what the blog post compares is the integral over the dotted grey line.
comment
Has there been a 1101% increase in excess deaths among children aged 0-14 across Europe in 2022?
@quarague I intentionally didn't try to analyze this any further, but the excess mortality would obviously be extremely sensitive to changes in the baseline. I think simply looking at the graph puts the claims into context, if you read "1000% increase" you'd usually expect a very different graph.
Loading…
awarded
awarded
comment
Did recently released internal Pfizer documentation show a much lower efficacy rate for the vaccine than previously claimed?
I suspect the 12% are from reports about the efficacy of the vaccine against infection in children, and the 1% is the ARR (Absolute Risk Reduction) for the vaccine which will always be a much smaller number than the relative values. But in the end a question with this kind of vague claims will boil down to a generic "do the vaccines work" answer, which we already have. So I'm not entirely sure what to do with this question.
revised
Loading…
comment
Does this article present an accurate summary of the (in)effectiveness of masks at preventing Covid-19 transmission?
You really need to pick a specific claim from the article, otherwise there are too many different claims at once.
revised
Loading…
awarded
revised
Is there an unusual distribution of adverse events by lot number for the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines?
clarified that this is only about the mRNA vaccines as mentioned in the body of the question
Loading…
1 2 3
4
5
78