56
votes
Accepted
Do 1.4 million Chinese people die each year because of air pollution?
The following is accurate according to a scientific report published in Nature:
Nature 525, 367–371 (17 September 2015) The contribution of outdoor air pollution sources to premature mortality on a ...
- 30.3k
50
votes
Did "fossil-fuel pollution [kill] three times as many people as COVID-19 did" in 2020?
The smoke and smog from those engines and appliances directly kill nine million people a year
I’ll address the “nine million people a year” estimate. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates ...
- 4,636
37
votes
Are chemicals in plastic causing a significant reduction in fertility?
Western world
Indeed, according to the Independent there is a crisis regarding fertility rates. But rather interestingly the same trend has not been observed in other parts of the world such as South ...
- 2,792
30
votes
Accepted
Did "fossil-fuel pollution [kill] three times as many people as COVID-19 did" in 2020?
The claim's specificity is probably not rock-solid, but the idea that fossil fuels kill huge numbers of people annually is sound.
I'm assuming McKibben was relying on this study from Harvard ...
25
votes
Accepted
Does clean air transmit significantly more UV?
Yes.
Based on [Relationship between surface UV radiation and air pollution in Beijing] from 2008 by An JL1, Wang YS, Li X, Sun Y, Shen SH.
This study also shows that a substantial reduction (up ...
- 2,785
24
votes
Did "fossil-fuel pollution [kill] three times as many people as COVID-19 did" in 2020?
The smoke and smog from those engines and appliances directly kill nine million people a year
In 2020, fossil-fuel pollution killed three times as many people as COVID-19 did.
The Dan Romik's answer ...
- 682
20
votes
Accepted
Are drinking straws a minor source of ocean plastic pollution?
Yes. Drinking straws are a relatively minor source of oceanic plastic pollution.
That is in perspective: Plastic drinking straws are a big problem in itself. But in comparison that problem is still a ...
- 44.1k
19
votes
Accepted
Do trees soak up pollution?
According to the US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service publication THE EFFECTS OF URBAN TREES ON AIR QUALITY
Trees remove gaseous air pollution primarily by uptake via leaf stomata,
though ...
- 105k
16
votes
Accepted
Can the oxygen levels in a polluted city be as low as 11%?
No, this is not possible. The health effects of such a low oxygen level would have caused mass exhaustion, headaches, symptoms such as bluing of the lips, and probably collapse among weaker citizens (...
- 2,533
14
votes
Accepted
Is burning 1ha of grassland more environmentally damaging than 6000 cars?
The African grass species Pennisetum purpureum was measured to produce 40 tons of dry biomass per hectare per year, of which about 44% is purely carbon. Does releasing the CO2 of 18 tons of carbon ...
- 2,883
14
votes
Is the European NO₂ limit of 40 µg/m³ for outside air backed by strong evidence?
Summary
The question as asked in the title depends on what you consider "strong evidence". I will therefore have a look at which side makes the better-sourced point. (Which is not just about "...
- 19k
14
votes
Accepted
Does breathing Beijing's air for one hour reduce life expectancy by 20 minutes?
This claim is difficult to evaluate in part because there are too many different variables at play. Fundamentally the reporter is quoting a statement by Richard Muller, Scientific Director of Berkeley ...
- 16.9k
14
votes
Do 1.4 million Chinese people die each year because of air pollution?
If we assume the Chinese to be average in dying due to air pollution, we can use global WHO estimates to assess how realistic this claim is.
WHO: 7 million premature deaths annually linked to air ...
- 17.7k
14
votes
Accepted
Does one cup of coffee pollute as much as a 10km car drive?
If by "pollution" you mean carbon dioxide release:
The Eco Guide discusses the amount of CO2 generated by coffee from growth through shipping to processing and the machines in the cafe where ...
- 7,653
11
votes
Are chemicals in plastic causing a significant reduction in fertility?
Are chemicals in plastic causing a fertility crisis?
I will be more assertive: SOME chemicals in plastics, or plastic coating, have proven effects on hormones and fertility.
For example bisphenol A, (...
- 210
10
votes
Does lowering speed limits by 10 km/h have any impact on air pollution?
Generally, every car has a specific speed where fuel efficiency (i.e. miles traveled per gallon) is highest. This is mostly around 40 - 60mph (~65 - 95 km/h). Above and below this speed fuel ...
- 1,960
10
votes
Accepted
Is Bhutan the only carbon neutral/negative country?
Is Bhutan carbon neutral?
According to "Sustainability in an Emerging Nation: The Bhutan Case Study" published in Sustainability, Bhutan is indeed carbon neutral. The paper makes the following ...
- 14.1k
9
votes
Is burning 1ha of grassland more environmentally damaging than 6000 cars?
This answer skims the line on how much calculation is allowed and will only talk about CO2 re: your guess that the claim relates to the amount of CO2 released by 6000 cars in one year.
According to ...
- 9,466
8
votes
Has the claim that there's a causal relationship between poor air quality and death been debunked?
This is effectively a partial answer. It does not seek to respond to the overarching question of whether or not there is a causal relationship between poor air quality and death. I'm not currently ...
- 3,647
8
votes
Are drinking straws a minor source of ocean plastic pollution?
According to Garbage Land: On the Secret Trail of Trash :
In 2002, International Coastal Cleanup volunteers in 117 countries collected 1.8 million cigarette butts and cigar tips, representing 31 ...
- 105k
8
votes
Is (or was) the air pollution in Beijing worse than "what the first responders at ground zero on 9/11 were breathing"?
Surprisingly, this is pretty easy to resolve:
9/11 First Responders Face A High Cancer Risk But Are Also More Likely To Survive
At first it was "pitch black," Cascio recalls. "We ...
- 1,121
7
votes
"In some cities, it's more dangerous to breathe than to smoke cigarettes."
I was considering the same question when I lived in Shanghai (a very polluted city indeed) and was told that many industrial cities in the north east of China was many times worse.
While smokers may ...
- 609
7
votes
Does lowering speed limits by 10 km/h have any impact on air pollution?
First, as far as I remember, there is a major factual mistake (possibly a mistranslation) in the article you quote. What happened is that speeds were reduced by 20 km/h in non-urban areas. I do not ...
7
votes
Have few, if any, studies on the health effects of particulate air pollution measured the actual exposure to particulates?
If anything, some studies suggest that the present measurement methods underestimate the effects:
A reanalysis of the data by Willis et al, restricted to people who live closer to the monitor, ...
- 59.7k
6
votes
Does the DuPont/Denka plant in Lousiana emit 250,000 pounds of chloroprene annually?
With the understanding that correlation does not equal causation, the EPA's study of air toxicity (search for St. John the Baptist Parish, LA) indicates that the levels of chloroprene adjacent to the ...
- 2,949
6
votes
Are chemicals in plastic causing a significant reduction in fertility?
There are two quite typical problems with the claim:
It's impossible to strictly prove a negative (as in "X has no impact on health"). It's only ever possible to evaluate a specific ...
- 2,447
5
votes
Accepted
Is Google causing 40% of the CO2 emission of all internet traffic?
In answer to the title of the question (see the addendum to this answer for details) No, Google does not cause 40% of the CO2 emissions of all Internet Traffic.
There's a case that can be made, ...
- 2,949
5
votes
Accepted
Does a coal plant "kill more in a few weeks than nuclear has ever killed"?
The claim as made in the original quote is fairly easy to debunk with sources from the comments because it compares deaths due to all nuclear power over all time with deaths of a single coal power ...
- 1,476
4
votes
Is the Taylor oil spill on the scale of Deepwater Horizon?
So, according to the Washington Post version of the story (also behind a pay wall), it's not clear exactly how large the spill is. However, recent analysis has shown that the Coast Guard National ...
- 141
4
votes
Is most of London's air pollution 'is caused by drivers from outside the capital'?
It's really hard to vet an article when the only reference is to a study located behind a paywall.
The only facts the article presents include:
12 million people who live outside London produced ...
- 611
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible