6

The news about Hira Raten Manek who seems to be able to survive on sunlight and liquids (including only water in some studies) had been in the local dailies some years back. There were reports that he had been studied by NASA too.

So is this a verified claim?

|improve this question
  • 1
    Liquid is a term that can include many different things. Small children survive a long time on a diet of milk. I see no reason why an adult shouldn't be able to survive 11 years through a similar diet. – Christian Nov 8 '11 at 14:12
  • I have read recently of a man who lived some 30 or 40 years on a diet entirely of cow's milk (due to some medical condition which prevented him from eating solid foods). But from a technical stand point, milk is not purely "liquid", of course. – Flimzy Nov 9 '11 at 5:51
  • There is nothing especially remarkable about humans surviving on a liquid diet. Plenty of nutrients can be pulped into a liquid. The remarkable claim would be that he only consumed water and survived 11 years, but the story sources don't seem to be unequivocal about that. – Lisa Nov 11 '11 at 0:30
  • The 'starving yogi' thing? google.com/hostednews/afp/article/… yes it was tested by some people and he passed the test. Since we know the result of the test is false we start doubting the people who ran it. – user5194 Nov 11 '11 at 9:14
7

In July 2003, noted skeptic, James Randi, investigated the claim that Hira Raten Manek was being tested by NASA.

Well, the official NASA spokesperson, Dolores Beasley, has now said she has no idea why press reports had claimed that NASA had invited Manek. NASA has no record of him being involved with them, in any way whatsoever. So, it's all a lie. What else is new?

This isn't much of a reference - one guy saying a spokesperson denied it.

But, really, for claims of this calibre (i.e. living without food, a claim that has been repeated made but never demonstrated in a reasonable test) how good does the counter-evidence have to be?

(That last link discusses other 'tests' that Hira Raten Manek submitted to. Note the lack of reports of independent tests where they don't somehow neglect to ensure he isn't eating.)

|improve this answer
  • 1
    Proving that something did not happen is always hard. If nobody can provide any evidence that this happened, a spokesperson denial seems enough to me. What however smells a bit to me is how can one make a statement like this? How does a spokesperson search through all NASA records? All all NASA records indexed digitally? – Suma Nov 8 '11 at 13:21
  • 1
    People eventually die without food. They also don't do photosynthesis so "surviving on light and water" is rather impossible. Source: any textbook for school students. Case closed? I mean, at least I see a clear difference between being a skeptic and playing a skeptic. – user288 Nov 8 '11 at 20:13
  • 1
    @Sejanus, we have someone standing up and effectively saying "The textbooks are wrong." In such a case, it is insufficient to point to assertions in those very textbooks as proof. We must go back and show how we know the knowledge in the textbook is true. All those theories could be undone with one solid piece of counter-evidence. Given the strength of the knowledge behind them, that would take an extraordinarily solid piece of evidence. Now, the question is "Is this evidence solid?" The media says "Maybe yes! Even NASA is checking it out." Randi says "No." – Oddthinking♦ Nov 8 '11 at 23:10
  • 1
    Well, right, but those textbooks are already based on solid research (or evidence, or counter-evidence if you wish). If you weren't able to find anything on this matter, current evidence (textbooks and researches they are based upon) would still suffice for any reasonable person, is what I am saying. NASA spokesman and stuff is just a nice bonus, cool to have yes, good job finding it. That's why yours is an answer and mine is a comment ;) – user288 Nov 9 '11 at 5:24
  • 2
    "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence..." – Joze Nov 10 '11 at 8:09

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .