-5

This post on Dec 1, 2021 by user @ItsMaoCena has the caption,

This Gucci manager be panicking every time they open their shop. As it should be.

China loves metaphors, and placing the ☭ ABOVE the Gucci logo is a very clear metaphor for the power hierarchy.

Guess who’s in control? It isn’t the Gucci CEO, that’s for sure.

Picture of GUCCI below hammer and sickle

Do they or have they shown communist symbolism above their local Gucci outlets?

4
  • 5
    Looking at one example of a hammer and sickle above a Gucci store, what makes you think that this applies to all Gucci stores in China and why in particular to Gucci?
    – quarague
    Dec 12 '21 at 20:16
  • Looking at my question, what makes you think I said "all"? Dec 12 '21 at 20:31
  • 13
    To my perception, in U.S. English, in your question's title, "their Gucci outlets" refers to them collectively, not just a single one, suggesting "all". That it might happen to a single one, by some random chain of events, is different (to my perception) than having it happen to all or most, collectively. To ask if this happened to just one is much less interesting than to ask about all, etc. Dec 13 '21 at 1:34
  • 5
    This looks like the "notable claim" is just one tweet by a person that is not obviously a public figure.
    – Dave
    Dec 14 '21 at 0:37
10

It appears to be an electronic display screen above the corner entrance of the IAPM shopping mall on Huaihai Zhong Road - the Baidu equivalent of Google's StreetView shows it in the daytime displaying nothing at all, along with a smaller "Boss" logo:

https://j.map.baidu.com/23/Vysc

The mall itself is described in a newspaper puff piece as "features nine duplex stores, which were designed to house international brands such as Prada, Mui Mui, Gucci and Valentino, and has a 220-metre-long shopping façade on Huaihai Zhong Road that is a rare sight in the Puxi area"

https://www.scmp.com/property/hong-kong-china/article/1399932/sun-hung-kais-late-night-iapm-mall-sets-new-benchmark

At least superficially the property developer is independent of the state, being a Hong Kong enterprise nearly 60 years old and more recently prosecuted for corruption (says WP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun_Hung_Kai_Properties).

Large electronic display signs have long been a feature of popular public spaces such as Times Square in New York or Piccadilly in London, and in general are available for displaying advertising, i.e. commercial or state propaganda. So while it's possible that this is a non-financial arrangement (display news of the Party Congress or get "investigated") the original story doesn't offer any evidence for this, and jumps to the unwarranted conclusion that this is Gucci being specifically forced to kowtow.

3

At least this one photo seems to be real: It is featured in an article from The Wall Street Journal, which is described as "Updated Dec. 10, 2017 11:59 pm ET" and according to the article "Appeared in the December 11, 2017, print edition", written by Chun Han Wong.

The photo is captioned as "Screens above a Gucci store in Shangha (sic!) show Communist Party symbols and General Secretary Xi Jinping's slogans, as part of a nationwide campaign to publicize the outcome of the party's 19th National Congress." It is credited with "PHOTO: JAMES T. AREDDY/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL". According to his WSJ author page, "James T. Areddy is a China-focused correspondent for The Wall Street Journal."

I'm unsure however where in the photo "General Secretary Xi Jinping's slogans" are displayed. Perhaps they were faded out of the LED display (if this is one) the moment the photo was taken.

The 19th National Congress of the CCP took place in October 2017.

It might be interesting to note, that the design of hammer and sickle seems to be specific to the Chinese Communist Party, and distinct from other designs such as the Soviet Union's, as may be seen from the "knob-shaped" handle of the sickle.

A similar photo showing hammer, sickle, and Chinese characters underneath appeared in an article of the art magazine frieze from 8th December 2017. The caption reads "Communist Party Propaganda above the Gucci shop, Shanghai, 2017", but the photo does not seem to be credited. Possibly, the display may show at least hammer and sickle, and hammer, sickle and some slogan alternating.

1
  • 1
    The Chinese in the image is 深入学习宣传贯彻党的十九大精神为建成富强民主文明和谐美丽的社会主义现代化强国而奋斗 (Google Translate: "In-depth study, publicity, and implementation of the spirit of the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, and strive to build a prosperous, democratic, civilized, harmonious and beautiful modern socialist country"). It's an advert for the upcoming 十九大 19th National Congress. I was here in China then, and such messages were basically everywhere, even in small towns. Dec 14 '21 at 0:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .