8

I heard that fruits and vegetable have much more vitamins when we eat them in normal way (biting) then when we use juicer and drink only the juice.

Is it true that juice from fresh fruit and vegetable is less quality and most of the healthy material is solid?

What percent of the vitamins, enzymes and other healthy stuff will end in the garden as compost after juicing?

I'm going to juice apples, oranges, carrot, broccoli and red beet most.

thank you

  • 2
    You lose much of the fiber when juiced. As well, it would seem like your body will absorb the sugars much more rapidly in this state, for the same reason that eating an apple is better for you than drinking pure apple juice. A slow breakdown of the fruit/veggies in your stomach is better for your body. At the same time, if you were not going to eat those beets otherwise, something is better than nothing. – user3344 Jul 9 '11 at 13:21
  • 2
    If you just want to consume the fruit as a fluid you should think about getting a mixer. It turns an apple into a fluid that contains all the stuff. – Christian Jul 9 '11 at 14:16
8

Regarding the nutrients, you're better off in general consuming the whole fruit, not just the juice. I'll look at oranges and apples. You can use the links and do the math to figure the same thing out for the other items, I imagine.

Orange vs Orange Juice

One medium orange (about 130g) contains 1.2g protein, 3.1g fiber, 116% daily value (DV) of Vitamin C, 8% DV thiamine, 10% DV folate, 7% DV potassium (K+), 5% DV calcium (Ca2+). (I am not including nutrients under 5% DV or sugars).

The juice of one medium orange (about 86g) contains 0.6g protein, 0.2g fiber, 72% DV Vitamin C, 5% DV thiamin, 6% DV folate, 5% DV K+, 1% DV Ca2+.

So by not including the pulp, you miss: 0.6g protein, 2.9g fiber, 44% DV vitamin C, 3% DV thiamin, 4% DV folate, 2% DV K+, and 4% DV Ca2+.

Apples vs. Apple juice

One medium apple with skin (about 180g) contains 0.5g protein, 4.4g fiber, 14% DV vitamin C, 5% DV vitamin K, 6% DV K+.

The juice of one medium apple (about 120g) contains 0.1g protein, 0.2g fiber, 1% DV vitamin C, no vitamin K, 3% DV K+.

Again, if you consume just the juice with no pulp or skin, you miss: 0.4g protein, 4.2g fiber, 13% DV vitamin C, 3% DV K+, and all 5% DV of the vitamin K.

The pulp and rinds of fruits and vegetables contain different amounts of nutrients than the flesh. This is more true in fruits like apples and oranges than in carrots and beets. Carrots and beets don't have a 'rind' and have brightly-colored flesh and juice, while an apple has certain nutrients that can only be found in the skin. In particular, if you drink only the juice you'll miss most of the fiber and protein.

Overall, you do get more nutrients consuming the whole thing - consider blending instead of juicing, maybe. Quality is subjective, so I won't address it.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .