5

It is common to hear elderly in Portugal saying that dining and then going to sleep has a bad impact on one's health (apparently it is not only in Portugal).

From this article we see that some foods may affect sleep

Such studies highlight a potential effect of macronutrient intakes on sleep variables, particularly alterations in slow wave sleep and rapid eye movement sleep with changes in carbohydrate and fat intakes.

However it is not clear to me how harmful the alterations in slow wave wave sleep and rapid eye movement are for one's health.

I do not want to get into much detail about problems that may result from eating before sleep, giving freedom to reflect upon them. They seem to be various, such as reflux, quality of sleep, or even weight gain, which, from this source is considered conventional wisdom:

Conventional wisdom says that eating before bed causes weight gain because your metabolism slows down when you fall asleep. This causes any undigested calories to be stored as fat.

Is sleeping right after a meal bad for one's health?


Related but raising a different concern: Does eating just before sleeping cause nightmares?

12
  • 2
    I'm pretty sure I've heard this claim here in South Africa too.Never seen it online but I think it is widely believed. – Jerome Viveiros Feb 19 at 14:11
  • 1
    @Oddthinking it is something I hear frequently. Apparently another user have heard as well (and lives in another country). If that is not enough, a simple Google search for "eating before bed" yields almost 1M results. Is this enough? If yes, should I add this information in the question? – Gonçalo Peres 龚燿禄 Feb 19 at 15:25
  • 1
    @Goncola - Medically, it is much harder to prove causation rather than correlation. For causation, you need a study where you make healthy people eat and then sleep for a few years, and you see if they become unhealthy. That is an ethically difficult study. Google "postprandial sleep" as a phrase. – Richold Feb 19 at 15:27
  • 3
    If lots of people believe it, it is reasonable to think you can find examples of people making the claim on the Internet. Include references to a few making the claim - quote the key claim they make. If they are in Portugese, it would be helpful to provide a short translation. Hopefully, we can tell from context what bad outcome they think will befall you - heart attack? diabetes? acid reflux? weight gain? Just a general "Oh, it is bad" will be very difficult to prove either way. When I search as you suggest, I get a page of debunkings, so that doesn't support your argument! – Oddthinking Feb 19 at 15:39
  • 1
    I have heard this claim numerous times over the past 30 years, from family, friends and probably other sources. Just doing a Google search turns up hundreds of articles. – glenneroo Feb 22 at 18:41
-2

Sleeping after eating a meal, or more specifically, laying horizontally, may lead to acid re-flux. So yes, very bad. There are also considerations to be taken into account for diabetes, insulin, and meal times and sleep time.

https://www.healthline.com/health/acid-reflux-at-night#prevention

Time it right. Wait at least 3 hours after eating before lying down. Improve your posture. Try standing up straight to elongate your esophagus and give your stomach more room.

https://www.webmd.com/asthma/guide/heartburn-asthma

Sleep with the head of your bed raised 6 to 8 inches so that gravity can help your stomach acid stay in your stomach. Don't eat for 3 to 4 hours before you lie down to sleep at night.

http://www.gastroenterology.com/conditions/gerd

https://gi.org/topics/acid-reflux/

Lifestyle Modifications

... Reduce weight if too heavy. Do not eat 2-3 hours before sleep.

Note: WebMd does list sources

5
  • 2
    Neither Healthline nor WebMD are reputable sources.... – Johanna Feb 19 at 19:12
  • @Johanna I could source CNN or WaPo. – paulj Feb 19 at 20:21
  • 7
    Those are still not good sources for health related claims. On this site, people typically cite actual medical research papers to support health related claims. – Johanna Feb 20 at 6:37
  • 2
    I would be skeptical of any claim that requires gravity for the operation of a healthy digestive tract. The digestive system is not a straight tube that doesn't work when horizontal. – ScienceGeyser Feb 26 at 9:22
  • 1
    @paulj Can you provide a specific title? I have actually read a number of texts concerning digestive anatomy and physiology as well as designing apparatus for digestive studies in laboratory & clinical settings, most of which are done supine. If someone has trouble lying down after a meal, it's most likely a problem with the food they consume or a digestive tract disorder, not the fact that they are lying down. – ScienceGeyser Mar 1 at 20:42
-9

According to Maimonides (Hamada, De'ot, 4;5), one should wait at least 3-4 hours before going to sleep after eating.

3
  • 2
    But why did he say that? Did he present any evidence that not doing so was bad for one's health? – jwodder Feb 23 at 13:23
  • @jwodder He doesn't present any evidence, although he himself is one of the most noted physicians of the early mediaval times. – Jacob3 Feb 23 at 14:36
  • 5
    On this site we are looking for answers that present empirical evidence. Unfortunately, this doesn't do that. The word of a medieval physician without his reasoning is merely "an appeal to authority". – fredsbend Feb 23 at 16:05

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .