47

A post on www.twitter.com [link] has garnered over 100K retweets and 345K likes which states:

So it turns out the monoclonal antibodies that Trump is on are from fetal stem cells. So Trump is being treated/saved with dead babies. Republicans? Amy Barrett? Pro-lifers? Anybody?

The implied relevance of this claim being that US conservatives have campaigned against the use of fetal stem cells in research for ethical concerns.

The original poster links to a document on www.regeneron.com [link] as a citation, which notably states:

The stem cells most commonly used at Regeneron are mouse embryonic stem cells and human blood stem cells.

As other people have pointed out in reply to the original post, this document leaves it unclear whether fetal stem cells were involved in the creation of Donald Trump's covid treatment.

Has Donald Trump received Covid treatment involving pharmaceuticals which were derived from human fetuses?

  • 11
    I'd note that this particular tweet is a little confused about the actual issue. While the monoclonal antibodies included in regeneron are not produced using human embryonic stem cells or fetal tissue, their discovery depended in part on research that used those cells and tissue. – De Novo Oct 8 at 4:32
  • 1
    Perhaps a more credible source, with a more accurate claim (also twitter): Dr. Eugene Gu, twitter.com/eugenegu/status/1313971637897756672?s=20 – De Novo Oct 8 at 5:04
  • 1
    Another potential source/claim: technologyreview.com/2020/10/07/1009664/… – lucasvw Oct 9 at 14:59
84

What Donald Trump received was a cocktail of two monoclonal antibodies. There are various ways to produce those, Regeneron does state on their homepage that they use Cell Lines for mass production. This does not mean stem cells, there are many cell lines that are not stem cells.

For research the antibodies are produced in mice, Regeneron calls their system for this VelocImmune.

I couldn't find a direct statement on which cell line they use on their homepage. But in an article in Science I finally found a direct statement that the antibodies are produced in Chinese hamster ovary cells:

The monoclonal antibodies from the two companies are clones of potent SARS-CoV-2 antibodies that can “neutralize” the virus in test tube studies. Researchers plucked the genes for these antibodies from humans who recovered from COVID-19 or from mice artificially infected with the virus. The companies then put the genes in Chinese hamster ovary cells to bulk manufacture the antibodies, which were given to the COVID-19 patients as infusions.

Chinese hamster ovary cells are not stem cells and neither are they human. No fetal tissue nor fetal stem cells were involved in the actual production of the antibodies.

There is one aspect of the development, but not production, of the antibodies where a cell line derived from fetal tissue was used. To generate a target that looks like SARS-CoV2 they used HEK293 cells. Essentially they modified a virus called VSV to contain the Spike protein from SARS-CoV2, and to mass-produce that modified virus they used HEK293 cells:

HEK 293 cells were generated in 1973 by transfection of cultures of normal human embryonic kidney cells with sheared adenovirus 5 DNA in Alex van der Eb's laboratory in Leiden, the Netherlands. The cells were obtained from a single, apparently healthy, legally aborted fetus under Dutch law; the identity of the parents and the reason for the abortion are unknown. Wikipedia

The HEK293 cell line was derived from a single aborted fetus (HEK = Human Embryonic Kidney). Cell lines are immortal, so all HEK293 cells in use in various laboratories all around the world are derived from that single first cell.

There are many different cell lines, another example are the CHO cells that were used to produce the actual antibodies that were originally derived from hamster ovaries.

HEK293 cells would not have been the only choice for these experiments. I found a paper describing similar experiments with a modified VSV that tested several cell lines for producing the modified VSV. You can see in figure 2 that they used Huh7, 293T, Hep3B, PLC/PRF/5, HepG2, HeLa, Vero and BHK. You can clearly see that the different cell lines were not all suited to the task, 293T was one of the best but the Huh7 cell line was a tiny bit better.

So strictly speaking, for one experiment designed to test how well the antibodies bind to the virus a cell line originally derived from fetal tissue was used. But stricter versions of this claim like e.g. that the research would not have been possible without fetal tissue are not supported in my opinion.

| improve this answer | |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .