In one presentation which has gone viral on Linkedin, author/motivational speaker Simon Sinek claims that US Navy SEALs select candidates for 'SEAL Team 6' by rating them by two characteristics: 'performance' and 'trust'.

He defines performance by how good candidates are on the battlefield, and defines trust by how good they are off the battlefield; for example, could they be trusted with each other's money and wives?

Allegedly selection for this elite team places higher value on trust than performance. And Sinek concludes from this that the business world needs to filter leaders by trust, owing to the destructive effects which often result from untrustworthy leaders; who gain power only through performance metrics and an absence of trust metrics.

Do US Navy SEALs select candidates for SEAL Team 6 by assessing 'performance' and 'trust' as defined by Sinek?

  • @BenBarden: Simon Sinek. (Edited link into question.) – DevSolar Nov 19 '19 at 14:32
  • 1
    It's still not clear if their performance with their colleagues' wives is rated – FooTheBar Nov 19 '19 at 15:12
  • 1
    @FooTheBar Is it clearer now? – inappropriateCode Nov 19 '19 at 15:14
  • The "Trust" component of this sounds like a load of bull. Everything I've read says that DevGru (the proper name for the team) is an elite selection process on top of the already elite selection process for Seals. Basic searches online very strongly support the case that performance is an extremely important aspect of acceptance, but "trust" seems to appear nowhere. It's also likely that, because of the strict requirements for recruitment, you're not going to have some fresh faced 21 year old on the team. From wiki, it appears that the minimum requirements force all members to be 30+. – DenisS Nov 19 '19 at 17:47
  • 1
    In short, no one gets into SOF without passing standards (performance). Most "pipelines" (selection courses) have a "peer-review" components - most of your peers have to like and "trust" you, or you will be "peered out". I know range school has this, would assume SEALs do too, but don't know for a fact. Physical performance and ability to not get injured during times of fatigue are 90% of selection. Everything else is very secondary. – VSO Nov 21 '19 at 19:06

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .