12

In this press release from The Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF), there is a claim that 500 prominent climate scientists and professionals has submitted a declaration that there is no “climate emergency”.

As the latest U.N. climate summit begins in New York, a new, high-level global network of 500 prominent climate scientists and professionals has submitted a declaration that there is no “climate emergency”.

I see the official letter but I don't see any signatures of scientists. Who has the list of scientists and does the list even exist?

  • 15
    This sounds very like the "500 'scientists'" who say that the Earth is only 6000 years old. – DJClayworth Oct 23 at 16:35
  • @DJClayworth, really? That's interesting. Where can I read about it? – Grasper Oct 23 at 17:08
  • 12
    it's interesting how they phrase it, "climate scientists and professionals" implies that there are 500 people who study the climate and aren't alarmed. However, "climate scientists AND professionals" allows them to link the one or two actual climate scientists that claim that with the much larger list of economists, programmers, doctors, engineers, authors, etc – DenisS Oct 23 at 17:27
  • 1
    @DenisS Actually, I take back some of what I said, because I found this: clintel.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/ecd-press-briefing.pdf directly on the clintel website. – DavePhD Oct 23 at 17:51
  • 1
    @DavePhD there we go, they lifted it directly from the Clintel people. Doesn't make it any more correct as a statement, but now the fault for the misleading headline falls directly on the Clintel group. – DenisS Oct 23 at 18:39
16

The list of 500 is available in this document.

The list is grouped by country and starts with:

SCIENTISTS AND PROFESSIONALS FROM BELGIUM

  1. Rob Lemeire, Publicist on Environmental and Climate Issues, ECD Ambassador
  2. Eric Blondeel, retired Civil Engineer.
  3. Emiel van Broekhoven, Emeritus Professor of Economics, University of Antwerp
  4. Christophe de Brouwer, MD, Honorary Professor of Environmental and Industrial Toxicology, Former President of the School of Public Health at the Université Libre de Bruxelles
  5. Christian Dierick, Lead Expert, Energy Technology Solutions
  6. Ferdinand Engelbeen, Former chemical process automation engineer, Akzo Nobel Chemicals
  7. Samuel Furfari, Professor of Energy Geopolitics at the Free University of Brussels
  8. Georges Geuskens, Emertitus Professor of Chemistry, Free University of Brussels and Expert Publicist on Climate Science
  9. Drieu Godefridi, PhD in Law, author of several books
  10. Jan Jacobs, Science Journalist Specializing in Climate and Energy Transition
  11. Raymond Koch, Retired Research director at Lab. Plasma Physics, RMA Brussels and Fellow Lecturer at UMons.
  12. Henri A. Masson, Emeritus Professor Dynamic System Analysis and Data Mining, University of Antwerp
  13. Ferdinand Meeus, Retired Research Scientist, IPCC expert Reviewer AR6
  14. Jean Meeus, Retired Meteorologist, Brussels Airport, Author of the Best Seller Astronomical Algorithms
  15. Ernest Mund, Honorary Research Director, FNRS, Nuclear Engineering
  16. Bart Ooghe, Geologist & Geophysicist, Independent Scientist
  17. Jozef Verhulst, Author
  18. Jean van Vliet, Retired Specialist in Space Weather
  19. Appo van der Wiel, Senior Development Engineer

The most are from Italy: 113.

The letter uses the phrasing "more than 500 knowledgeable and experienced scientists and professionals in climate and related fields". Not all are "scientists" as per the title that the OP wrote. As seen above, one person is simply listed as being an "author" and another is listed as "PhD in Law, author of several books".

  • Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. – Oddthinking Oct 29 at 3:31
  • And has anybody checked that these are real people? Could some/many/all of them be just made up names and titles? It's easy to find 500 nutjobs to sign anything, even easier to make them up. – user8356 Nov 22 at 14:17
10

Yes the letter has been signed by 500 people but very few of them are actual climate scientists or in related fields (environmental science, ecology, etc).

Many of them have links to oil companies and/or climate denying groups.

Many of the claims in the letter are wrong and have been debunked.

Here is what actual scientists think about the letter and the claims it makes: https://climatefeedback.org/evaluation/letter-signed-by-500-scientists-relies-on-inaccurate-claims-about-climate-science/

  • 3
    You may want to add some quotes from the link you provided for posterity sake and to back your points up about the 500 people who signed. There are some good quotes in that link that would effectively back your answer up much better. Otherwise this is a good answer. – DenisS Oct 24 at 20:47

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .