4

Ann Cameron, author of “Curing Cancer with Carrots”, claims that her cancer was cured by carrot juice, and recommends it as a treatment to others, as a potential substitute for chemotherapy.

I followed Ralph Cole’s protocol, which he developed by experimentation with quantities. He found that juicing three pounds of carrots daily stopped his tumors from growing but didn’t eliminate them. After he increased his juicing to five pounds of carrots daily, his small tumors (eight of them, each about the size of a grain of rice) disappeared entirely in eight weeks. On the evidence of Ralph’s experience, I juiced five pounds of carrots daily for close to eight months. After seven weeks of carrot juicing, a CT showed that the tumors between my lungs had stopped growing and had shrunk slightly. At four months, they were no longer visible on CT and my lungs were normal.

...

Carrot juicing can enhance the positive effects of radiation and chemotherapy and reduce their damages. To play it safe, one can use radiation and chemo and carrot juice at the same time. But because chemotherapy is toxic, if an oncologist says a delay in starting chemo will not greatly increase one’s risks, I would recommend a person newly diagnosed with cancer try carrot juice alone first for a period of six weeks, and then to get a CT scan. If at that point there’s been growth in the cancer, I’d recommend adding chemotherapy or another treatment to continued carrot juice drinking.

The Anti-Cancer Properties of Carrots

Is the consumption of carrot juice a cure for cancer?

0
17

No, there is no evidence to support this claim, because she is claiming to have cured a cancer that was never diagnosed.

Via Dr David Goski's Respectful Insolence blog:

For example, Ann Cameron claims to have cured herself of stage IV colon cancer with carrot juice. She had stage III colon cancer, underwent surgery, and refused chemotherapy. Later, she was noted to have lesions in her lungs suspicious for metastases. These supposedly disappeared with carrot juice. However, there is no record of any of these lesions having been biopsied. A PET scan showed "spots" that looked like lymph nodes, but again there is no mention of these lesions ever having been biopsied. My conclusion? These almost certainly were not metastatic cancer.

So she is claiming that carrot juice cured a cancer that she claimed appeared after the cancer that was successfully treated with surgery.

3
  • 3
    This answer may be incomplete but I am snowed under at work right now. I did find some vague refutation on the general claim on Cancer Research UK, but not specific enough to include here. In any case, it seems the writer didn't actually have the cancer she claims to have cured with carrot juice. – Jerome Viveiros Sep 23 '19 at 7:12
  • 8
    And even if it happened as described: drinking a lot of carrot juice while your cancer disappears does not equal "cured through juice" – Borgh Sep 23 '19 at 11:41
  • 2
    And even if it actually cured her cancer it is no proof that it can cure any other cancer (cancer is not one disease, but several thousand different diseases, possibly even a specific type only found in one patient). – ghellquist Sep 26 '19 at 20:26
-6

Ann Cameron is not the only person who has survived cancer using carrot juice. It is not new. The Gerson method has been around for years. And it is not true that she was never diagnosed. She certainly was and endured the removal of part of her colon and abdominal muscle. That is something they don't do without a diagnosis! My husband is suffering from end-stage cancer and he was in super poor condition until we were gifted a juicer from a cancer survivor and we started juicing carrots and oranges. He was unable to keep hydrated or eat much at all. He was so weak he could barely speak or stand. Now, he is loud and clear and has begun to work again and his job is physical. People should try things before they discourage others from doing them.

New contributor
Stephen Dennis is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering. Check out our Code of Conduct.
2
  • I'm glad to hear about your personal circumstances having improved so after such setbacks. Might I invite you to take our tour and read-up in the help center about how we work, you'll find that answers here have standards of evidence that must be produced to support arguments, not only personal testimony. Welcome to skeptics Stephen. – A Rogue Ant. 18 hours ago
  • You're disputing a claim that Jerome's answer didn't make. She was diagnosed with colon cancer, which was surgically treated, but she also claims to have cured a cancer in her lungs. It's the lung cancer that was never diagnosed. Jerome's answer makes that very clear. "People should try things before they discourage others from doing them." I mean, most of us can't exactly try curing our cancer with carrot juice because most of us don't have cancer. – F1Krazy 6 hours ago

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .