4

bands in town

My main skepticism comes from the fact repeated exposure to loud music seems detrimental more than anything else, but I'd gladly be shown to be wrong.

After a little digging, the original claim is on the 02 website and the logic appears to be based on increased feelings of well-being and how that links with increased life expectancy. However, I can't see any liked studies or additional studies to prove their point

  • Can you tell is more about the source of the claim and provide link? – Christian May 18 '18 at 7:35
  • 1
    @Christian found original source and added to body – Cursed May 18 '18 at 7:49
  • 13
    Being able to afford to go to concerts increases life expectancy? Yeah, I'd buy that. – Daniel R Hicks May 18 '18 at 12:03
  • @Daniel Lol, I was thinking exercise, mental health, etc. I like the way you think. – fredsbend May 19 '18 at 17:34
2

I looked for it, but the original study hasn't been released, so we can only speculate based on the press release.

Wellbeing increased by 21% from just 20 minutes of gig-time, compared to just 10% for yoga and only 7% for dog-walking

They probably asked people how good they felt 20 minutes into the concert. Better than after doing yoga, that's plausible. But there is no reason to assume you feel better after the concert ends - if it did they'd mention it.

They want to imply that going to concerts will bring permanent benefits by arguing:

Accompanying research showed a positive correlation between regularity of gig attendance and wellbeing.

A positive correlation could be something like r = 0.03 (almost nothing) - we don't know. But one thing is always true: "Correlation doesn't equal causation". It's more plausible that extroverted people - who are happier on average (many studies, for example: http://psycnet.apa.org/record/1981-10468-001) - seek out more concerts.

additional scholarly research directly links high levels of wellbeing with a lifespan increase of nine years

I don't know what research they are referring to here. Most papers in that direction face the difficult question "Are these people healthy because they are happier or are they happier because they are healthier?".

This study suggests that "positive affection" does make you live longer, even when controlling for other factors. I don't know how to convert an odds ratio of 0.962 (for mortality) into years (maybe somebody of you does). But considering the fact that we don't have proof for concerts permanently increasing your happiness, we can also be skeptical that they will increase your lifetime by 9 years.

Additionally, if concerts increase your happiness permanently, they will only be a small fraction of what makes you happy, so talking about 9 years is in no way appropriate.

Please prove me wrong, but as it stands I'd call the articles "clickbait with no basis in reality."

  • Nice answer, especially considering the study hadn't been published. – Yisela Sep 11 '18 at 16:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .