17

Floating around Facebook

enter image description here

Caption reads:

Before 2009, NFL Players did not stand for the National Anthem, they stayed in the locker room. The custom didn't start until the Dept. of Defense gave the NFL $5.4 Million Dollars to stage on field ceremonies to make the teams seem more patriotic.

  • 4
    Snopes says it is a mixture: snopes.com/nfl-sideline-anthem. There was payments to NFL teams to stage ceremonies, but a) that doesn't seem to have a connection to the national anthem, b) players always had the option to be on the field for the anthem. re the payments: pbs.org/newshour/rundown/… – rougon Sep 24 '17 at 21:50
  • The misconception might have come from here dailysnark.com/nfl-teams-didnt-stand-national-anthem-2009 It says that it's quoting slate.com and gives the link, but it doesn't say that in the link. I don't watch football, maybe they did all start standing out for the national anthem about the time of the DOD funding. Otherwise, there's no connection that patriotic ceremonies meant having to stand out for the anthem. The DOD got a lot of flack for using money this way. – John Dee Sep 27 '17 at 22:11
13

According to the 1987 book American Football:

Every football game is preceded by a playing of the American National anthem. Rivalries are temporarily forgotten as fans and players stand to pay tribute to their country.

Sociology of American Sport (1978) says:

The concern of league officials is exemplified in the efforts of Pete Rozelle, commissioner of the National Football League, to have all players show proper respect for the national anthem (the athletes are told how to stand, how to hold their helmets, etc.)

Additionally, Win Peace and Freedom Thru Nonviolent Action, Volume 7 says of Dave Meggyesy

Meggyesy feels that his first real political commitment came in 1963, his first year in pro football ... The Cardinal management tried to dissuade Meggyesy from his radical involvement, but to no avail. In fact, he went on to make his house a sort of meeting place for the St. Louis radical movement, to circulate petitions among his teammates ... to refuse to stand at attention with the rest of the St. Louis team when the national anthem was played.

For more information, see Meggyesy's 1970 book Out of Their League starting at the bottom of page 245, where he explains that coach Charley Winner (who had been held as a prisoner of war by the Nazis) lectured the team on exactly how to stand at attention during the national anthem. Then he writes:

I'd thought a lot about this and decided that saluting the flag was ridiculous. Every time I even looked at it, I saw only a symbol of repression, so I decided to protest. My original idea was to pull a Tommy Smith by raising my right fist in the air and bowing my head. ... When the National Anthem started I stepped out of line and began kicking the dirt and holding my helmet down in front of me with my two hands. My head was bowed and I was spitting on the ground and moving from side to side scuffing the ground with my shoes.

So not only is standing for the national anthem at profession football games a long tradition, the idea of refusing to stand at attention as a form of protest is as old as the 1960s.

Generally speaking, the tradition that football players (not necessarily professional) should remove their helmets and stand at attention during the National Anthem, facing the flag or facing the music if there is no flag, is at least as old as the 1950s, as explained in the Michigan High School Athletic Bulletin:

Participants in football uniforms should remove their helmets and stand at attention with the helmet held in the hand at the side.

15

Not true, at least not as a rule ("they always were in the locker room during the anthem").

There are plenty of pre-2009 videos available showing NFL players attending the anthem.

Whether or not they always were on the field, that's harder to establish, as there are also videos around that don't show players (because they weren't on the field, or because the cameraman didn't deem it important to show them).

  • Downvoter: As you didn't leave a comment on how you think this answer could be improved, I can only guess that you would have preferred the answer to be "true". Don't hit on the messenger, and don't confuse statement of fact with statement of opinion. Or, better yet, leave a comment to go with your downvote... – DevSolar Sep 26 '17 at 14:12
  • 1
    Since the claim in the question does not say "always", I don't think an answer should necessarily be binary. So while a few counterexamples are useful and interesting, I think it would be much more useful and interesting if there were some sources that could indicate whether the teams stayed in the locker room "very often", "very rarely", or something in between. – ff524 Sep 26 '17 at 16:51
  • 3
    @ff524 The answer represented its evidence accurately and is up front about the completeness of its evidence. I invite you to write an answer for "very often", or "very rarely." – BobTheAverage Sep 27 '17 at 14:19
  • One of the example videos is from a game played on foreign soil (UK), where it seems (at least to me) more likely players would stand and/or outwardly display patriotic gestures. Another is from an inherently US-centric holiday game (Thanskgiving). I don't know how well they represent an average game during the time period, so they're not inherently useful to me except to say "yes, this has happened at least three times in all of history." – Is Begot Sep 28 '17 at 14:31
-2

Yes and no, to be honest. There was no requirement that players be on the field for the anthem for all games.

However, there was no rule or policy that they stay in the looker room, either. Basically, where the players were depended more on the logistics of the spectacle of the game, before 2009.

Prime time games, played at times other than the standard game times (Sundays, 1 PM ET and 4 PM ET) would have the field cleared so the network could set up the pre-game logistics without having to work around players milling about the field. Regular-timed games were on a tighter schedule, so the players were already on the field and ready to go right after the anthem. Being on that tighter schedule, the anthem was generally not broadcast before the regular-time games.

Spokespeople for the NFL have said on several occasions -

Players are strongly encouraged, but not required, to stand.

and

We believe our players have a right to express themselves

A short history of the national anthem, protests and the NFL | PolitiFact

Snopes FACT CHECK: Why Are NFL Players on the Sidelines for the National Anthem

So, what is clear is that there is no requirement, now, for players to stand and recognize the anthem. Where the players are is more a matter of where they need to be in order to participate in games from the start.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .