5

From a comment by Amnesty International Australia's Facebook account, since deleted, with a screenshot having 212 retweets and 235 likes (text courtesy of the Algemeiner)

The countries that banned the passport have done so for a reason. They are aware of the atrocities committed by the Israel Defence Force and have seen Palestinians being displaced from their homes for the illegal settlements.

I know that motivation questions aren't allowed, so rather than trying to look at motivations, I'll look at dates - whether the purported cause occurred before the effect. I've done some searching, but while there's plenty of articles mentioning the ban on Israelis, I haven't found so far mention of when the bans started.

Did the ban on Israelis postdate the construction of Israeli settlements which involved Palestinians being displaced?

  • 5
    Several of those countries have never recognized Israel and presumably not accepted its passports. Many of them may say that Palestinians started being displaced in 1948 (the year of Israel's independence, when more than 700,000 Palestinians either left their homes or were expelled) or earlier. Wikipedia has several articles – Henry Feb 4 '17 at 1:56
  • @Henry were those displacements being done to create illegal settlements? – Andrew Grimm Feb 4 '17 at 2:04
  • 2
    One can argue that the whole of Israel is an 'illegal settlement', just like the British 'illegally' took over Israel's modern territory in the first place. Your question is therefore primarily opinion based. – JonathanReez Feb 4 '17 at 9:32
  • 4
    @JonathanReez - one can argue that Arabs illegally took over that territory that belonged to Jews in 7th century and on. Let's stick to the actual legal claims, such as they are, and not political rhethoric. – user5341 Feb 4 '17 at 12:40
13

Wikipedia has a handy map of countries that have ever recognized Israel:

enter image description here

The Muslim-majority dark-pink countries (such as Saudi Arabia) have never recognized Israel and never accepted Israeli documents in the first place. However there are four countries that withdrew recognition:

  • Iran: severed relations after the Islamic Revolution in 1979
  • Chad: withdrew recognition in 1972, however Israeli travelers are not banned
  • Mali: withdrew recognition in 1973, however Israeli travelers are not banned
  • Cuba: withdrew recognition in 1973, however Israeli travelers are not banned

Therefore the claim is false: Iran severed relations for unrelated reasons and the other three countries still admit Israeli passports.

Also note that Amnesty International Australia themselves withdrew their claim and apologized for the statement:

On Tuesday 31 January, a comment was posted on the Amnesty International Australia Facebook page regarding travel restrictions on Israeli passport-holders. The comment did not reflect Amnesty International’s position on this issue, and as such we would like to apologise for any misunderstanding this comment has caused.

5

The Arab League announced a policy of boycotting Israel (or rather the Jewish residents and organizations of Palestine) in 1945. The passport issue is an extension of this boycott. There were local boycotts beginning in the 1920s.

At this point, all Jewish controlled land in Palestine was bought from Arab landowners and there were no "settlements" of the sort that is now described as "illegal settlements"

There is an Arab landlord with Arab peasants working his land. When he sells his land, the Jews want to work the land themselves and don't renew the peasants' tenancies and they lose their jobs. This pissed off Arab nationalists like Qassam and was one of the causes of the 1936 Palestine riots.

Summary: Boycott began in 1945.

Jewish settlement (lower case) displaced Arabs before 1945, but there were no Jewish Settlements (Upper Case) yet.

Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.

  • 1
    Please provide sources for your answer. – SIMEL Feb 5 '17 at 12:13
  • which assertions require sources? – Clint Eastwood Feb 7 '17 at 18:18

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .