8

enter image description here

According to this image circling the Internet, Clinton is on record this week saying that she is a life long Cubs fan. Yet her previous statements claim she's been a Yankee fan for years.

Did she claim to be fan of both teams?

  • 4
    Is the implication supposed to be that only one can be true? – Is Begot Nov 7 '16 at 20:38
  • 1
    @IsBegot i think both Can be true, im more interested personally to know if her cubs statement is simply bandwagoning, or if she has prior claims of support. – Himarm Nov 7 '16 at 20:41
  • 3
    Ok, but "fan" is a very fuzzy concept. What objective standard would we use to determine whether or not she was a fan of any given sports team at any given moment in time? – Nate Eldredge Nov 7 '16 at 21:13
  • @NateEldredge the questions simple. being a fan is based on the honor system, she says shes always been a fan, were looking to see if she has previously stated this in the past to self confirm, or a statement in the past self deny. – Himarm Nov 7 '16 at 21:15
  • Let's avoid pointless arguments. I've re-edited the question so it's not about the exact quotes, but her self-reported affiliation. – Sklivvz Nov 7 '16 at 22:46
15

Yes, Clinton has self-admittedly been a fan of both clubs for years.

We can see from her opponents' view on the issues (obviously painted with a negative slant) that Hillary Clinton has claimed to be a long-time fan of both the Cubs and Yankees.

GOP.com (the website of the Republican Party, Clinton's opponent in the elections) claims that (emphasis mine):

In the early 1990s, Clinton pledged allegiance to the Cubs, claiming she’d been a lifelong fan in an interview with Esquire. But running for the Senate in New York, Clinton claimed she’d “always been a Yankees fan.”

In 2006 Clinton Said The Cubs And Yankees Were Her Favorite Teams “Growing Up And Now In My More Mature Years.”

CLINTON: “Thank you very, very much, Jonathan. I don't have time to rebut everything you've said in your introduction. But I cannot let stand that I have ever, ever been a Mets fan. Have to set the record straight. Cubs and Yankees: Those were my teams, and remain my teams, growing up and now in my more mature years.” (Hillary Clinton, Remarks, Washington, DC, 5/23/06)

While Running For Senate, Clinton Said That “She'd ‘Always Been A Yankees Fan.’”

“Later, Clinton asserted that she'd 'always been a Yankees fan.' Couric correctly challenged her, saying she thought the first lady, a native of Illinois, was a Chicago Cubs fan. 'I am a Cubs fan,' Clinton said. 'But I needed an American League team … so as a young girl, I became very interested and enamored of the Yankees.’”

Clinton has claimed consistently to be a fan of the Yankees since 1999, therefore she is qualified to claim that she has been a Yankees fan for years (although her support before 1999 is doubtful).

She has also consistently claimed that she had always been a Cubs fan while growing up, and that she chose to support the Yankees as well because the Cubs were not winning enough.

  • 1
    perfect exactly what i was looking for, ill let it chill for a day or so but most likely accepted – Himarm Nov 7 '16 at 23:53
-3

Hillary is a fan of both.

“So I had to search for a team that would counterbalance the experience of losing every single year, so — I hate to say this, and I know you’ll probably boo me — I became a Yankees fan.”

Clinton explained: “I alternated my affections because it was just too hard only being a Cubs fan. But absolutely a Cubs fan.

  • 8
    Avoid derogatory comments. Consider this a warning. – Sklivvz Nov 7 '16 at 22:47
  • 8
    The whole point about so-called "sports bigamay" adds nothing to the question; the first quote tells us everything we need. The rest is editorializing at best. – user23048 Nov 7 '16 at 23:18
  • 7
    No, it describes one person's personal opinion of the phenomena - even the analogy "you can only have one wife" is invested in cultural bias. I recommend removing it. – Oddthinking Nov 7 '16 at 23:23
  • 6
    Let's avoid pointless exchanges of accusations and ridicule. @KDog: this answer has multiple flags complaining of rudeness. While I don't personally think it is explicitly rude, you may want to make sure it is appealing to the general public as it's attracting downvotes. – Sklivvz Nov 7 '16 at 23:41
  • 7
    "Skepticism" on this site pretty much means fact-checking. That's it. Yes, it does make for a bland clinical experience, but those are the rules. – fredsbend Nov 8 '16 at 3:03

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .