21

From Alternet: Ignorant America: Just How Stupid Are We?, July 1, 2008 (referring to polls conducted over the past three decades):

Which country dropped the nuclear bomb? Only 49% [of Americans polled] know it was their own country.

Do (or did in the three decades prior to this article) only 49% of Americans know which country bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki?

  • 1
    A better attribution of the source is Richard Shenkman, "Just how Stupid are We?: Facing the Truth about the American Voter" books.google.com/… – DavePhD Jul 25 '16 at 18:04
  • 1
    In a later edition of the book he changed "Only 49% know it was their own country" to "A majority of Americans do not know that it is their own country that is the only one to have used nuclear weapons. " books.google.com/… – DavePhD Jul 25 '16 at 18:11
17

Richard Shenkman is taking his information from the 1997 book What Americans Know about Politics and why it Matters, and has corrected the statement in the 2010 version of his book.

The 1997 book says 91% stated "The U.S. used A-bomb against Japan" in a 1990 survey. (page 87, table 2.7)

and also says 49% "correctly" answered a survey item "only nation to use nuclear bomb" in a 1986 survey (page 88, table 2.7); and separately (page 84, table 2.5) the book says 49% for "only nation to use nuclear weapons" in a 1986 survey.

According to the May/June 1986 Deadline, Nuclear Times article "What We Know About Arms Race Is More Than a Matter of Opinion" by Jay Rosen:

To test public knowledge, the Center [for War, Peace and the New Media] designed two questions that Roper included in a recent 42-item opinion survey. In the first, Roper's 1,993 respondents were given four statements about the use of nuclear weapons and asked to choose the correct one. Forty-nine percent knew that the U.S. "is the only nation to have ever used nuclear weapons against another nation in time of war." Eleven percent believed we never dropped the bomb, 10 percent thought the U.S. and the Soviets both had used nuclear weapons, and another 13 percent said that other nations had employed nuclear weapons during a war. Seventeen percent said they didn't know.

57% responded that the United States was the first country to develop a nuclear weapon according to a 2015 survey.


According to the Quebec Agreement:

Whereas it is vital to our common safety in the present War to bring the TUBE ALLOYS project to fruition at the earliest moment; and whereas this may be more speedily achieved if all available British and American brains and resources are pooled; and whereas owing to war conditions it would be an improvident use of war resources to duplicate plants on a large scale on both sides of the Atlantic and therefore a far greater expense has fallen upon the United States;

It is agreed between us

First, that we will never use this agency against each other.

Secondly, that we will not use it against third parties without each other's consent.

The USA and UK, in accordance with the above earlier agreement, 4 July 1945 jointly agreed to use the atomic bomb against Japan as recorded in the Minutes of a Meeting of the Combined Policy Committee:

Use of Weapon Against Third Parties. FIELD MARSHAL WILSON stated that the British Government concurred in the use of the T. A. weapon against Japan.

  • 2
    How does it relate to the 49% figure in the claim? – Mindwin Jul 25 '16 at 19:54
  • 3
    Ok, if you remove the unnecessary aside about the Quebec Agreement, I can upvote this. – called2voyage Jul 25 '16 at 21:21
  • 1
    @called2voyage I don't mind downvotes, I think it's important for people to know it was a joint decision. The Japan Times also thinks it's important for this recently declassified information to be known. japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/08/04/national/history/… – DavePhD Jul 25 '16 at 21:27
  • 6
    This answer is very useful, and indicates there's a seed of truth to the alternet claim. However, it's probably useful to indicate the exact wording of the question asked and the option chosen, and how many people chose not to give an answer. I think wording matters, because countries other than the US tried developing a nuclear weapon pre-1945, and countries other than the US have exploded nuclear weapons, albeit not in a country they're at war with. – Andrew Grimm Jul 26 '16 at 2:42
  • 2
    @AndrewGrimm I added the exact wording, format, and other responses. – DavePhD Jul 26 '16 at 11:51

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .