22

enter image description here

It has been my understanding that

EMF detectors are used for a wide variety of applications. For example, EMF detectors can be used to measure electrical leaks in microwave ovens as well as other industrial electronic appliances. EMF detectors are also used to detect the presence of electricity in power lines and can even measure free-flowing electromagnetic fields in space. Because visible light, ultraviolet light, infrared light, microwaves, x-rays, and radio signals are all forms of electromagnetic waves, they can all be measured by EMF detector. source

However, I constantly see people on tv running around dark, sometimes decrepit buildings waving these things blindly at every sound while looking for ghosts and calling it "science".

I have also seen people asking questions aloud to a dark and empty room, then considering any flash or blinking light on the EMF meter to be some kind of "answer" or evidence of some "presence".

The sites I have found about how to "properly use an EMF meter" mostly come from paranormalist websites and read as an exercise in how to use some gadget with blinking lights to anomaly hunt while being able to technically call it science.

It would seem to me that even if we were to grant that ghosts exist, this would not be a reliable way to detect their presence, given the range of things that these meters can detect, and the number of things that can cause interference. Also, I have been told that the majority of paranormalists are using the meters inappropriately, and even if ghosts were to exist, their readings would be unreliable because it is almost impossible to tell if a reading is anomalous unless a reliable baseline reading is taken and the building is monitored for an extended period of time.

I have also heard that these meters are used to detect fields occurring for reasons other than the supernatural, which may cause a "fear cage" effect similar to that of the Koren Helmet as explained by Michael Persinger. However, this is not related to what I have seen the bulk of these meters used for.

  • Is there a scientific reason to think that an anomalous electromagnetic field has anything to do with the supernatural?
  • Where did the idea that EMF meters can detect ghosts come from? Why has it become so widely accepted?
  • 4
    Whether or not EMF meters can detect ghosts depends on the characteristics of ghosts. Unfortunately the research about them is pretty scare. – Christian May 10 '11 at 22:33
  • 3
    I honestly think at least part of the cause is the movie "Ghostbusters", where Egon uses a scientific-looking device with flashing lights and little arms that raise when a ghost is nearby. In other words, it gives ghost hunters credibility by association with a device that actually performs a scientific function. It probably also looks good on camera. – John Lyon May 10 '11 at 23:20
  • 15
    I am afraid the only possible answer is "what do you mean by ghosts, scientifically?" – Sklivvz May 10 '11 at 23:21
  • 1
    I was interested more in how the paranormalists justify to themselves and others the reasons for using these meters. What is it that makes some of them think that despite the lack of evidence over the years of searching for supernatural entities that EMF detectors will somewhow yield legitimate evidence? It is kind of hard to deal with that degree of magical thinking in logical, scientific terms. Perhaps I should edit. – Monkey Tuesday May 11 '11 at 0:07
  • 2
    It's hard to come up with a "scientific reason" why anything would be able to detect fictional creatures. What's the scientific reason silver kills werewolves? What is it precisely about the sun's EM radiation that afflicts harm on vampires? Are real zombies fast or slow, and what function of their metabolism makes them desire delicious brains? – John Rhoades Aug 9 '11 at 14:22
20

Where did the idea that EMF meters can detect ghosts come from? Why has it become so widely accepted?

enter image description here

(But seriously, they were scientists and used beepy flashy things to detect ghosts)


This 2005 article states that EMF meters have been used for "ghost hunting" for decades:

[A] major stimulus of today's tech-heavy ghost-hunting trend happened in 1984: The film "Ghostbusters" was released.

...No one really knows what kind of influence a ghost might have on the environment, so ghost hunters try anything and everything.

"If we're doing a full-scale investigation, it goes from the simple electromagnetic-field meters" -- handheld devices that have been ubiquitous on ghost expeditions since the early 1990s -- "all the way to digital video recorder systems with between eight and 12 cameras, depending on the size of the place," said Gloria Young, founder of the Santa Clara group Ghost Trackers. Young also uses a Geiger counter, which measures radiation; motion detectors; barometric pressure monitors; and thermometers.

It goes on to quote a quotes a prominent ghost hunter:

Ghost hunting has grown in the past two decades from a little-known hobby to a much more popular pursuit. Ghost hunters say that, judging from the number of ghost-hunting organizations with Web sites, there are hundreds of groups with thousands of members in the United States.

And technology is a major force behind the trend, said Loyd Auerbach, director and founder of the Office of Paranormal Investigations in the East Bay.

"It was the late 1980s when things began to expand, and part of it was the availability of certain types of technology that we started using in the field," like electromagnetic-field detectors, which start at around $100, Auerbach said. "Part of it was seeing people like me on TV."

There has probably been a recent rise in popularity of EMF meters being used to detect ghosts that tracks the rise in popularity of shows like "Ghost Hunters" where they use the device, among others, to "detect ghosts". Because if you use scientific equipment, you must be doing science, right?

The two featured investigators, Jason Hawes and Grant Wilson, are proudly blue-collar workers, not egghead Ph.D. scientists, which adds to their strong "regular guy" appeal. ...They claim to be skeptics but are very credulous and seem to have no real understanding of scientific methods or real investigation.

But if you're on TV, you have to appear legitimate. From the original cited article:

"If you take the human factor out and just have this instrument, it (seems to) confer some legitimacy -- which these folks desperately want,"

More recently, all-in-one "ghost detector" devices have been released, which I presume are riding the coattails of popular shows such as these.


Is there a scientific reason to think that an anomalous electromagnetic field has anything to do with the supernatural?

No, and ghost hunters themselves cannot cite a single possible theory that EM fields are related to the supernatural. This Live Science article quotes a prominent ghost hunter:

An EMF meter is among the most common devices used by ghost hunters today. I spoke to Tom Cook, of TomsGadgets.com, a British purveyor of "scientific" paranormal kits for the enterprising (and gullible) investigator. Starter kits begin at £105 (US$180) and reach up to £500 (US$850) for a custom ghost-hunting kit. (Negative Ionizer Ghost Containment packs were not listed.)

I asked Cook what, exactly, the scientific rationale was behind the equipment he sold.

"At a haunted location," Cook said, "strong, erratic fluctuating EMFs are commonly found. It seems these energy fields have some definite connection to the presence of ghosts. The exact nature of that connection is still a mystery. However, the anomalous fields are easy to find. Whenever you locate one, a ghost might be present.... any erratic EMF fluctuations you may detect may indicate ghostly activity."

In the final analysis, Cook admitted, "there exists no device that can conclusively detect ghosts."

From the Wikipedia page on Ghost Hunting:

EMF meter: to detect possibly unexplained fluctuations in electromagnetic fields.

Unfortunately in addition to being vague, that line does not cite any sources. So, if one believes (without basis) that ghosts somehow cause "unexplained" fluctuations in electromagnetic fields, the EMF meter would be a valid piece of equipment for hunting ghosts.

Considering the other methods and equipment listed there include dowsing rods, ghost boxes, psychics, clairvoyants and demonologists, it's unlikely that any ghost hunters have commissioned scientific studies into why background EMF levels would fluctuate without an explainable cause.

But really, to a ghost hunter (or TV watcher) an EMF meter is a beeping, flashing device that can "go off" seemingly randomly (though why that might occur is a separate question), which makes things exciting.

You must log in to answer this question.

protected by Community Feb 1 '13 at 3:37

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .