-1

The following research claims that there is a link between high "racial resentment" (as measured by answers to questions in the survey) and support for VoterID laws.

Here, CPC researchers found an interesting pattern in the data: it is Democrats and liberals whose opinions on voter ID laws are most likely to depend on their racial attitudes. Republicans and conservatives overwhelmingly support voter ID laws regardless of how much “racial resentment” they express. In contrast, Democrats and liberals with the highest “racial resentment” express much more support for voter ID laws than those with the least resentment (see Figure 3).

Researchers claim that he has found a link between being a non-black Democrat with high racial resentment and supporting VoterID laws, but no link between being a non-black Republican with high racial resentment and supporting VoterID laws.

I'm wondering if his research holds up to close scrutiny? Does this appear to be real science?

Is racial resentment towards African Americans correlated with Democrats support of a political position?

  • Please see meta the other copy was changed to its original content and this is not a dupe anymore. – Sklivvz Sep 9 '12 at 19:35
  • 1
    This question suffers a lack of notability. Despite the "I'm wondering" wording, it is clear from the (now deleted) instant answer that the OP does not doubt the claim. Hence, we need some link to show there is a dispute to resolve. – Oddthinking Sep 9 '12 at 21:02
  • 1
    @Oddthinking, odd isn't it. Not a single close vote for the Q. regarding free market types and refuting "accepted" science, and yet this one gets closed within minutes. It is almost as if it goes against a commonly held myth in America. skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/10793/… – user1873 Sep 9 '12 at 21:06
  • Funny that this is studying the black/white conflict when the primary target of the voter id laws would be Hispanics in the country illegally, and people trying to defraud they system by casting votes as someone else. I would think those views would be more important in this area. – Chad Sep 10 '12 at 20:46
1

Racial resentment against African-Americans across all party-political lines corresponded with higher support for voter ID laws, according to one study at the Centre for Political Communication at the University of Delaware, of attitudes among non-African Americans.

Correlation between racial resentment and support for Voter ID across all party-political lines

For every sample sub-group, including Republicans, Conservatives and Democrats, support for voter ID was higher among people who expressed higher racial resentment against African Americans, than among groups who expressed lower resentment.

Republicans showed the highest support for voter ID laws, compared to Democrats and Independents; they also showed the highest resentment against African Americans, compared to Democrats and Independents. Given a total sample size of 906 people, the study was unable to say much of statistical significance about views on Voter ID within the small sub-group comprising of Republicans who expressed little or no racial resentment against African Americans. However, no mechanism was suggested that would support diversion from the trend in the sample as a whole, within which racial resentment against African Americans correlates with support for Voter ID; and the sample data is consistent with the hypothesis that higher racial resentment corresponds with support for voter ID among Republicans, just as it does among other groups, inclusing Democrats.

The study reports:

The link between “racial resentment” and support for such laws persists even after controlling for the effects of partisanship, ideology, and a range of demographic variables.

So, for example, among Republicans, those few with lower racial resentment against African Americans, had 87% support for voter ID laws. Whereas among those Republicans who expressed higher resentment against African Americans, the support for voter ID laws was 93%. Within Democrats, both the levels of racial resentment and the levels of support for voter ID were lower: 47% of Democrats with low racial resentment supported voter ID; 77% of Democrats with high racial resentment supported voter ID. Overall, Democrats scored just 0.32 on the racial resentment scale (0.0 would be least resentment, 1.0 would be most), whereas Republicans scored 0.54

Problems with sub-group sample sizes

NB the error margin in the whole sample is 3.9%

So the sample consisted of too few Republicans with low racial resentment, to be able to say much (with statistical significance) about their views on voter ID, relative to Republicans with high racial resentment. The study does not give any explanation about why it was hard to find enough Republicans who expressed little-to-no racial resentment. All we know from the report of the survey is that racial resentment against African Americans was higher within Republicans than within any other group. By comparison, the lower support for voter ID within Democrats, and the lower racial resentment, means that there are higher sub-group samples within each of the four quadrants of: support for voter ID yes/no plotted against racial resentment high/low.

In summary

From the University's report of the survey:

Brewer, the center’s associate director for research, said, “These findings suggest that Americans’ attitudes about race play an important role in driving their views on voter ID laws.”

(my emphasis)

Closing thoughts on correlations

Note that this is a study of correlation and corresponding attitudes: not of reasons why people support voter ID or not.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .