Skip to main content
Commonmark migration
Source Link

It's important not to overstate this, because a variety of factors are probably at play. But one big theory about why the rates of heroin relapse were so low on return to the U.S. has to do with the fact that the soldiers, after being treated for their physical addiction in Vietnam, returned to a place radically different from the environment where their addiction took hold of them.

 

"I think that most people accept that the change in the environment, and the fact that the addiction occurred in this exotic environment, you know, makes it plausible that the addiction rate would be that much lower," Nixon appointee Jerome Jaffe says.

Here is what happened in Vietnam: Soldiers spent all day surrounded by a certain environment. They were inundated with the stress of war. They built friendships with fellow soldiers who were heroin users. The end result was that soldiers were surrounded by an environment that had multiple stimuli driving them toward heroin use. It's not hard to imagine how living in a war zone with other heroin users could drive you to try it yourself.

 

Once each soldier returned to the United States, however, they found themselves in a completely different environment. Not only that, they found themselves in an environment devoid of the stimuli that triggered their heroin use in the first place. Without the stress, the fellow heroin users, and the environmental factors to trigger their addiction, many soldiers found it easier to quit.

It's important not to overstate this, because a variety of factors are probably at play. But one big theory about why the rates of heroin relapse were so low on return to the U.S. has to do with the fact that the soldiers, after being treated for their physical addiction in Vietnam, returned to a place radically different from the environment where their addiction took hold of them.

 

"I think that most people accept that the change in the environment, and the fact that the addiction occurred in this exotic environment, you know, makes it plausible that the addiction rate would be that much lower," Nixon appointee Jerome Jaffe says.

Here is what happened in Vietnam: Soldiers spent all day surrounded by a certain environment. They were inundated with the stress of war. They built friendships with fellow soldiers who were heroin users. The end result was that soldiers were surrounded by an environment that had multiple stimuli driving them toward heroin use. It's not hard to imagine how living in a war zone with other heroin users could drive you to try it yourself.

 

Once each soldier returned to the United States, however, they found themselves in a completely different environment. Not only that, they found themselves in an environment devoid of the stimuli that triggered their heroin use in the first place. Without the stress, the fellow heroin users, and the environmental factors to trigger their addiction, many soldiers found it easier to quit.

It's important not to overstate this, because a variety of factors are probably at play. But one big theory about why the rates of heroin relapse were so low on return to the U.S. has to do with the fact that the soldiers, after being treated for their physical addiction in Vietnam, returned to a place radically different from the environment where their addiction took hold of them.

"I think that most people accept that the change in the environment, and the fact that the addiction occurred in this exotic environment, you know, makes it plausible that the addiction rate would be that much lower," Nixon appointee Jerome Jaffe says.

Here is what happened in Vietnam: Soldiers spent all day surrounded by a certain environment. They were inundated with the stress of war. They built friendships with fellow soldiers who were heroin users. The end result was that soldiers were surrounded by an environment that had multiple stimuli driving them toward heroin use. It's not hard to imagine how living in a war zone with other heroin users could drive you to try it yourself.

Once each soldier returned to the United States, however, they found themselves in a completely different environment. Not only that, they found themselves in an environment devoid of the stimuli that triggered their heroin use in the first place. Without the stress, the fellow heroin users, and the environmental factors to trigger their addiction, many soldiers found it easier to quit.

added 1 character in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102

1More More specifically, the authors wrote that 1% of interviewees were addicted to heroin a year after the war. If the 1% were all already addicted to heroin (which was true for 19% of interviewees) then 1/19 or 5.26% of interviewees were still addicted to heroin a year after the war. If, instead, not all of the 1% were addicted to heroin in Vietnam then < 1/19 (and > 94.74%) of interviewees who were addicted remained addicted. Thus, the percentage of US soldiers who stopped is at least 94.74%. In the paper cited above, Robins wrote:

1More specifically, the authors wrote that 1% of interviewees were addicted to heroin a year after the war. If the 1% were all already addicted to heroin (which was true for 19% of interviewees) then 1/19 or 5.26% of interviewees were still addicted to heroin a year after the war. If, instead, not all of the 1% were addicted to heroin in Vietnam then < 1/19 (and > 94.74%) of interviewees who were addicted remained addicted. Thus, the percentage of US soldiers who stopped is at least 94.74%. In the paper cited above, Robins wrote:

1 More specifically, the authors wrote that 1% of interviewees were addicted to heroin a year after the war. If the 1% were all already addicted to heroin (which was true for 19% of interviewees) then 1/19 or 5.26% of interviewees were still addicted to heroin a year after the war. If, instead, not all of the 1% were addicted to heroin in Vietnam then < 1/19 (and > 94.74%) of interviewees who were addicted remained addicted. Thus, the percentage of US soldiers who stopped is at least 94.74%. In the paper cited above, Robins wrote:

added 527 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102

This 2010 paper more specifically mentions only 5~5 percent of Vietnam War veterans who were addicted to heroin took heroin 1 year after the war. (I will check this later. See end of answer for specific sentence from a different paper.)1 The authors also write (emphasis added):

You can read more about the effect of the environment in this excellent article written by Robins (who led the original research time authorized by Nixon). Quoting one sentence

1More specifically, the authors wrote that 1% of interviewees were addicted to heroin a year after the war. If the 1% were all already addicted to heroin (which was true for 19% of interviewees) then 1/19 or 5.26% of interviewees were still addicted to heroin a year after the war. If, instead, not all of the 1% were addicted to heroin in Vietnam then < 1/19 (and > 94.74%) of interviewees who were addicted remained addicted. Thus, the percentage of US soldiers who stopped is at least 94.74%. In the paper cited above, Robins wrote:

In the first year after return, only 5% of [soldiers][US soldiers] who had been addicted [to heroin] in Vietnam were addicted in the US.

The percent of interviewees addicted to heroin did increase over time.

This 2010 paper more specifically mentions only 5 percent of Vietnam War veterans who were addicted to heroin took heroin 1 year after the war. (I will check this later. See end of answer for specific sentence from a different paper.) The authors also write (emphasis added):

You can read more about the effect of the environment in this excellent article written by Robins (who led the original research time authorized by Nixon). Quoting one sentence:

In the first year after return, only 5% of [soldiers] who had been addicted [to heroin] in Vietnam were addicted in the US.

This 2010 paper more specifically mentions only ~5 percent of Vietnam War veterans who were addicted to heroin took heroin 1 year after the war.1 The authors also write (emphasis added):

You can read more about the effect of the environment in this excellent article written by Robins (who led the original research time authorized by Nixon).

1More specifically, the authors wrote that 1% of interviewees were addicted to heroin a year after the war. If the 1% were all already addicted to heroin (which was true for 19% of interviewees) then 1/19 or 5.26% of interviewees were still addicted to heroin a year after the war. If, instead, not all of the 1% were addicted to heroin in Vietnam then < 1/19 (and > 94.74%) of interviewees who were addicted remained addicted. Thus, the percentage of US soldiers who stopped is at least 94.74%. In the paper cited above, Robins wrote:

In the first year after return, only 5% of [US soldiers] who had been addicted [to heroin] in Vietnam were addicted in the US.

The percent of interviewees addicted to heroin did increase over time.

Separate paragraphs with elipses instead of stating they are separate.
Source Link
Loading
added 48 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 171 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 171 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 2 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 28 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 1437 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 1437 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 483 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 330 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
added 330 characters in body
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading
Source Link
Barry Harrison
  • 14.2k
  • 4
  • 69
  • 102
Loading