Reputation
9,817
Top tag
Next privilege 10,000 Rep.
Access moderator tools
Badges
2 44 79
Newest
 Yearling
Impact
~258k people reached

Sep
29
answered Is there a correlation between voting for the Democratic Party and gun crimes in the USA?
Sep
28
comment Is Miss America Organization the world's largest provider of scholarship assistance for young women?
A nice effect of Oliver's reporting is that the Society of Women Engineers received $25K in scholarship donations the following week: time.com/3426950/john-oliver-women-scholarships
Sep
25
comment Are Muslims allowed to deceive non-Muslims through a practice called Taqiyya?
The 2nd and 3rd opening points of lettertobaghdadi.com seem extremely relevant.
Sep
25
comment Are Muslims allowed to deceive non-Muslims through a practice called Taqiyya?
Aren't questions relating to a religion's precepts and goals inappropriate for this stackexchange?
Sep
23
answered Were Native Americans given blankets intentionally contaminated with smallpox?
Sep
23
comment Is it possible to identify one's nationality through one's handwriting?
I'm not sure this is the proper forum for this question, but it's interesting. Would you say it's a difference in lettering format (which could be a particular form taught in certain places) or is it a difference in the style (slant, pressure, etc.) with which they are laid down?
Sep
23
comment Is the “I before E” English spelling rule not very useful?
One needn't be omniscient to see that the rule is inefficient. Science is sufficient for proficient and conscientious fanciers to see that the rule is deficient in our society.
Sep
23
comment Were Native Americans given blankets intentionally contaminated with smallpox?
The link in the question relates to a different accusation: that the US Army deliberately infected the Mandans in 1837. The Ft. Pitt event was in 1763. (The Ft. Pitt event establishes that the answer to the question is "yes," though.)
Sep
19
comment What is the use of the questions on the US Visa Waiver form?
Friend of a Friend accidentally checked "Yes" on one of these several years ago and is still questioned every time he comes to America. My favorite question is "as a government official, been responsible for...particularly severe violations of religious freedom?" "Particularly severe? No, not particularly severe."
Sep
14
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
Voting to close since, as I've discussed in comments, I think the question, as it stands, constitutes cherry-picking that reduces it to a non-notable claim.
Sep
14
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
A less potentially-inflammatory analogy would be the difference between the questions "Did Lance Armstrong deny using PEDs?" (IMO not notable) and "Did Lance Armstrong consistently deny using PEDs?" (IMO potentially notable)
Sep
14
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
What I'm saying is that the question/claim posted on Skeptics is supposed to be notable. IMO, "Did X ever say Y?" is rarely a notable claim unless coupled with "...and never the opposite" or "...and denied having said that Y," or somesuch. Otherwise, it feels like cherry-picking. (And just to reiterate, I posted the answer when "...and consistently" was part of the question and commented that I think the question should be reverted to that. Otherwise I would apply my just-stated reasoning and vote to close.)
Sep
14
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
@Sklivvz As I commented on the post itself, it seems to me the OP quote does not constitute a significant claim absent the original wording that Bin Laden "consistently" denied involvement. I think it's highly misleading to cherry pick an exculpatory claim. The site has clearly evolved from scientific skepticism to broad fact-checking, but at least it has maintained some discipline with "significant claim."
Sep
13
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
I would suggest that his initial statements are not the notable claim. The notable claim relates to whether his statements, in totality, support or undermine his involvement.
Sep
13
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
The source video uses this quote to promote the concept that 9/11 was a false flag conspiracy. It is absolutely relevant that Bin Laden was not consistent after his initial denial and in 2004 took responsibility. I suggest that the question be restored to its original form.
Sep
13
revised Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
added 72 characters in body
Sep
13
revised Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
added 72 characters in body
Sep
13
comment Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
To my reading, "we decided to attack the towers" and "...this came to my mind" are clear and direct statements of his involvement. If your point is that he denied involvement initially, that's true, but these quotes show that (one way or the other) he was not "consistent" in what he said.
Sep
13
answered Did Osama Bin Laden immediately deny involvement in the 9/11 attacks?
Sep
5
revised Is it very difficult to kill a whale at sea humanely?
Removed statement "Humane is hard to define"