Skeptics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for scientific skepticism. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

A while ago a NASA funded study claimed that they could get bacteria to incorporate arsenic into their DNA.

Life forms based on different elements than life on earth have been speculated about in science fiction for a long time, the most prominent, hypothetical example is probably silicon-based instead of carbon-based life. Now, arsenic and phosphorus are in the same group in the periodic table like carbon and silicon are. This is the first study I know of that claims that life based on different elements is really possible.

Did they conclusively show that life forms based on arsenic-containing DNA are possible, or is this an overhyped and exagerrated conclusion?

share|improve this question

Here's a article from a scientist pointing out the flaws in the research --

Basically the measurements are in question, due to sloppy controls.

In a more general sense, in order to conclusively show something, someone not supporting NASA would have to replicate the experiment. So far that has not happened. So far, most of the press is on how badly they screwed up protocols.

Other articles

Right now it appears to be in the one experiment and a lot of opinions stage, which is very from from conclusive.

share|improve this answer

You may enjoy the article NASA did not find arsenic-based life.
Those bacteria can use arsenic instead of phosphorus if forced to, but do not use it naturally. Yet this achievement is still cool.

share|improve this answer
Even the “instead of” part is questionable. For example, the research failed to show conclusively that the bacteria actually incorporated arsenic into their DNA, and given what we know about the structure of DNA this is highly unlikely. – Konrad Rudolph Mar 17 '11 at 18:14
This fails to address the question of whether or not arsenic-based life is possible. – Avi Mar 11 '13 at 17:23
@KonradRudolph "Quantitative Study of As (V) and As (III) Interaction with Mangrove DNA by Molecular Fluorescence Spectroscopy" Bull Environ Contam Toxicol (2014) 93:177–181 studies the replacement of phosphate with arsenate and arsenite in DNA in vitro. – DavePhD Feb 19 at 13:48

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.