Tell me more ×
Skeptics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for scientific skepticism. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I noticed this book, "Grey Wolf: The Escape Of Adolf Hitler", mentioned (without real criticism) in a major Icelandic newspaper. According to the article, the book claims Hitler did not kill himself, and the authors claim to have proof that he lived in Argentina until he died from natural causes in 1962.

Amazon describes the book thus:

Did Hitler (code name Grey Wolf) really die in 1945? The evidence says no. Heres the gripping story of what might have happened... When Truman asked Stalin in 1945 whether Hitler was dead, Stalin replied bluntly, No. As late as 1952, Eisenhower declared: We have been unable to unearth one bit of tangible evidence of Hitler's death. What really happened? Simon Dunstan and Gerrard Williams have compiled extensive evidence, some recently declassified, that Hitler actually fled Berlin and took refuge in a remote Nazi enclave in Argentina. The recent discovery that the famous Hitler's skull in Moscow is female, as well as newly uncovered documents, provide powerful proof for their case. Dunstan and Williams cite people, places and dates in over 500 detailed notes that identify the plan's escape route, vehicles, aircraft, U-boats and hideouts. Among the details: the CIA's possible involvement and Hitler's life in Patagonia, including his two daughters.

Has anyone here read the book?

Is there any proof of these claims?

Is there any proof of his death in 1945?

share|improve this question
1  
+1 This question just profoundly unsettled me. Thank you for contesting supposed truth! – Joze Oct 17 '11 at 8:37
9  
I don't think the intention of this site is for other people to read stuff for you. – DJClayworth Oct 17 '11 at 13:23
3  
Because its an anecdote I cant use this as an answer but one of the reviews says "No Hard Credible Documentation or Actual Evidence"... I Think that pretty much sums it up. There have been lots of conspiracy stories about Hitler living in the Andes until the 80's or 90' I swear every few months the National Enquirer or its ilk would run a story about how he had been found/killed/arrested... – Chad Oct 17 '11 at 15:48
What could the CIA possibly have gained by helping Hitler escape, besides the possibility of an enormous, treasonous scandal? – BlueRaja - Danny Pflughoeft Nov 1 '11 at 23:01
Answering and voting down. A first for me. – denten 2 days ago

1 Answer

The death of Hitler is extensively documented, with copious source material summarized in the Wikipedia article on the Death of Adolf Hitler.

The authors' claim of being "unable to unearth one bit of tangible evidence of Hitler's death" in light of that bibliography is utter sensationalist bunk.

A cursory look at the book reviews on Amazon confirms numerous errors, the fabrication of facts, and a general lack of supporting evidence for the authors' claims.

All of this could have been gleaned from a basic, third-grade book report, internet search.

share|improve this answer
The first reviewer cites The Daily Mail (and a person contacted by The Daily Mail). Should we trust a review that cites them? – Andrew Grimm yesterday
@AndrewGrimm agreed – denten yesterday
This is a good answer – however, unfortunately I have to remove the quote since it’s extensive and doesn’t fall under fair use. Could you maybe include just the salient portions needed to underscore your answer? In its current form it’s a copyright violation. – Konrad Rudolph yesterday
I beefed up the sentence that offers a summary of Amazon reviews. Thank you for the edits @KonradRudolph. – denten 11 hours ago

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.