Take the 2-minute tour ×
Skeptics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for scientific skepticism. It's 100% free, no registration required.

According to a number of websites, "almost everything you have been told about heartburn, indigestion, and common stomach ailments are lies", and heartburn is actually caused by too little stomach acid.

The truth about most stomach disorders is that they are caused by not having enough acid, so the industry has made fools out of most of us. The true reason behind acid reflux and indigestion is that when the stomach is lacking enough acid, it must churn violently to make the best use of its limited acid during these times of deficiency, which in turn causes pressure and back flows of the existing acid.

Why You Should Use Apple Cider Vinegar Instead of Antacids and Baking Soda for Indigestion

What has Apple Cider Vinegar been Successfully Used for? Acid Reflux Syndrome (Heartburn)

Drinking apple cider vinegar is supposed to fix this by adding acid to the stomach.

The science behind the apple cider vinegar cure for heartburn is simple–the stomach uses natural acids to digest food, and apple cider vinegar is very similar in acidity to your stomach acid. Heartburn happens when there is too little acid in the stomach itself to digest your food.

No More Heartburn - Organic Apple Cider Vinegar

http://heartburncureshq.com/322/apple-cider-vinegar-for-heartburn-relief/

Some people who experience heartburn may not have enough digestive acid.. Apple cider vinegar is acidic in nature and thus it helps. If the sphincter esophagael contains the acid, it closes the LES (lower esophageal sphincter) to protect the esophagus by reflux. And the LES is to open at regular intervals when there is too little acid.

Apple Cider Vinegar For Acid Reflux Treatment

Is there any truth to this? I tried apple cider vinegar once, and not only does it taste and smell terrible, it made my heartburn worse.

share|improve this question
2  
Be wary of taking apple cider vinegar tablets; they can damage your throat. Hill, L; Woodruff, L; Foote, J; Barretoalcoba, M (2005). "Esophageal Injury by Apple Cider Vinegar Tablets and Subsequent Evaluation of Products". Journal of the American Dietetic Association 105 (7): 1141–4. doi:10.1016/j.jada.2005.04.003. PMID 15983536. I'd certainly recommend talking to your doctor before taking them. –  Oddthinking Jul 4 '11 at 13:08
1  
I wouldn’t try to ingest any acid that comes close in acidity to stomach acid. Did you ever notice how some top models have very bad teeth? This happens when teeth come into contact with stomach acid … –  Konrad Rudolph Jul 5 '11 at 9:15
4  
Here is what I wonder about this question: Stomach acid has a pH of 1. pH is a logarithmic scale. According to the second link provided above, ACV has a pH of around 2.8-3.0. Also, dosing recommendation is 1 part ACV to 4 parts water. Given all of this: is that small amount of ACV even going to affect the environment of the stomach? There may be something else going on here that I don't understand, but as far as I can see it seems unlikely that the vinegar will have any effect. –  nalgenegirl Jul 6 '11 at 17:41
3  
Also: stomach acid is hydrochloric acid (a strong acid). ACV is acetic acid (a weak acid). It's not as if you are giving your stomach more hydrochloric acid to "help" it digest better. Are these claims assuming that all acids are the same? I'm not understanding this based on the premise alone. –  nalgenegirl Jul 6 '11 at 17:57
2  
@nalgenegirl: Strong vs weak doesn't really matter, since it's already accounted for in the pH. Furthermore, gastric acid is usually diluted to ph 1.3 - 3.0. –  MSalters Jul 7 '11 at 11:58
show 1 more comment

1 Answer 1

up vote 9 down vote accepted

No.

First, it's wise to define heartburn as gastric reflux, to exclude ischaemic heart disease. The suggested "churning" hypothesis doesn't relate to heart disease at all.

Second, there does exist a feedback mechanism to deal with a lack of gastric acid. That's not (as the vinegar peddlers suggest) mechanical, but simply chemical. Gastric acid is hydrochloric acid, which the body can synthesize from salt and water—you'd be dead before you run out of the building blocks!

A further problem with the vinegar theory is that Histamine (H2) receptor antagonists are FDA approved medicines, from which we can conclude they work better than placebos. The vinegar theory implies that they'd work worse than placebos, because they reduce acidity, not increase it.

share|improve this answer
    
I wasn't aware there was any other definition of "heartburn" –  endolith Jul 8 '11 at 3:06
1  
The gastrin component of the feedback also stimulates gastric motility so their proposed mechanism does theoretically exist (I very much doubt that theory holds up in practice however). –  NonSequitur Jul 10 '11 at 1:28
1  
The idea that hydrochloric acid is synthesized with only (table) salt and water is undermined by your link showing that, for example, potassium is involved. I think that point could be safely removed from the answer. –  Oddthinking Nov 19 '12 at 22:41
    
@Oddthinking: As the link also notes, potassium is recycled. It's a catalyst, not a building block. –  MSalters Nov 20 '12 at 11:53
    
@MSalters: But if you're potassium-deficient, it could conceivably limit your ability to produce acid? –  endolith Feb 6 '13 at 22:52
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.