Take the 2-minute tour ×
Skeptics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for scientific skepticism. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Manhattan Beach, CA in 1983 members of the McMartin family were accused of a variety of abuse charges against the children in their care.

It was reported that the children:

  • "were victimized by teachers who were members of an intergenerational Satanic conspiracy."

  • "were required to participate in "major, major sacrifices" connected
    with the "Satanic Church." source

There were all manner of other abuse allegations filed, but in the end all accusations were found to be either baseless or completely disproven. The case has become now become an example of a modern-day witch hunt.

It lasted six years -- the longest US criminal trial in history. At a cost to the state of $15 million, it was also the most expensive. No convictions were obtained. The main evidence of abuse was based on what the children testified were memories of repeated, sadistic, ritual molestation. Years later, child psychologists realized that such memories can be easily implanted in children's minds by the interview techniques which were used at the time. Since psychologists and police investigators have changed their methods of interrogating young children, no more MVMO cases have surfaced in the U.S. and Canada. The children's testimony was supported by medical tests, which were believed at the time to be accurate. Years later, they were found to be useless. same source

While no one can argue that throughout history, there have been killings where religious inspiration is a primary motive, in America the spectre of satanic cult killings looms mostly in stories, movies, and urban legends which tend to crop up around particularly gruesome or unexplained murders. These claims reached a peak in the 1970-1980's.

It seems logical, even for skeptics that since believers of most faiths gather together to practice their rituals and worship that satanic churches or cults could logically be assumed to do the same.

But do these rituals really include murder and human sacrifice?

A quote from the church of satan states

Due to the high volume of mail that we receive from young people who are new to Satanism, we have put together some information to help answer your specific questions and concerns.

If you have read our books, you know that Satanism isn’t about taking drugs, and it isn’t about harming animals or children. Unlike many religions and philosophies, Satanism respects and exalts life. Children and animals are the purest expressions of that life force, and as such are held sacred and precious in the eyes of the Satanist. Besides, it is very un-Satanic to take any creature’s life against its will. source

However, there any many, many cases where organizations (public,religious,private,legislative) have said one thing and practiced another.

After some searching I have found may claims which have been hard (or impossible) to verify that satanic churches or cults have committed anywhere from hundreds to thousands of murders nationwide over the years.

However, I have been unable to find any hard evidence for specific cases where a satanic church/cult has been proven guilty (or legitimately claimed responsibility for) of either ritual murder or human sacrifice.

While the church of satan does exist, I can find no evidence that it is engaged in any national conspiracy to commit ritual murder/sacrifice and/or cover up evidence of such.

But you can find internet warnings such as

There are an estimated 100,000 or more Satanic cults in America. Those numbers sadly are out-dated and from the 1980's. The numbers are much higher now of course. But it's not a priority of the F.B.I. to track anymore. Police are NOT allowed to call a ritual murder done to someone as so. There are certain codes for these type Satanic murders source

The question is...

Is there any evidence that there are organized satanic churches or cults committing ritualistic murder and/or human sacrifice across America? Or is this another conspiracy theory/urban legend which could be possible, but has little to no proven basis in reality?

The question isn't...

  • meant to include murders committed by individuals who claimed satanic motives after the fact or to account for the actions of disturbed or mentally ill individuals.
  • meant to include speculation as to whether or not any other religion is spreading this information to further their own agendas
  • About anyone's personal beliefs regarding the existence of satan.
  • Able to be answered by saying "satan covered up the evidence"
share|improve this question
1  
Why limit it to the US? I have evidence regarding Italy. –  Ebenezer Sklivvze Apr 29 '11 at 21:15
2  
This is often brought up together with False Memory Syndrome: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_memory_syndrome –  Lagerbaer Apr 29 '11 at 21:17
1  
@sklivvz Honestly, I did that out of laziness. I thought it might become problematic to track down and verify primary sources from around the world and have to translate from say, Farsi. Also, I thought I might run into a problem with evidence presented from decisions based in areas under the rule of religious/tribal dictatorships where people can still be executed for being a witch. But I will edit to remove US from the title and see how it goes. –  Monkey Tuesday Apr 29 '11 at 21:53
2  
During the heyday of this nonsesne (I'm in law enforcement) police agencies were subjecting their officers to training on "how to spot signs of Satanic activity"..... The Skeptical Inquirer did a number of articles on all of this back then; though I don't know if they are in the online archives; it's been awhile. –  M. Werner Apr 30 '11 at 14:38
2  
(continued from above) As you may recall, the FBI came out with a flat statement to the effect that there was no sign of any such activity whatever. Much as in the claims of "millions" of people being abducted by UFOs without their knowledge, we had people claiming that "hundreds of thousands" of individuals and infants were being ritually murdered in these activities. But no evidence ever surfaced. Sure, there may be a few lunatics who think their anti-social activities are being directed by "Old Nick", but they are just deluded whackos. –  Ebenezer Sklivvze Apr 30 '11 at 14:39

1 Answer 1

up vote 12 down vote accepted

In Italy, we had the Beasts of Satan killing 4 people for "Satanic" reasons, of which at least two in a satanic ritual.

enter image description here

To give a bit more context: two of the killers confessed to the murders and the motivation, the rest of the sect, also jailed, maintains that it was only the work of the two killers, and that the confessions are false and motivated by reduction in jail time.

So on these basis, I think we can believe that at least the self-accused killers have been committing murders with a satanist ritualistic intent.

The wikipedia article only has links to the news. More reputable information, via Google translate, follows. I've been fixing the translation where not good.

From the CESNUR web site, the Center for Studies on New Religions:

In addition, one of the accused, Mario Maccione, was thought to be a medium, as other members believed it to be "possessed" by demons during the celebration of the homemade rites performed by the group. Even the murder of Marino and Tollis seems to be part of a satanic ritual context, however - partly because of the defensive strategies adopted by lawyers in various ways - the stories about the facts given by the accused in court show some discrepancies. In any event, on the evening of the disappearance, Fabio Tollis and Chiara Marino were killed with edged weapons and blunt instruments and thrown on top of each other in a hole, dug some days before by Pietro Guerrieri.
source

According to the acts of the tribunal (in the words of one of the accused on his blog):

According to Maccione, the group was devoted to spiritualism, and he was the medium that was in a trance (p. 3), the demons spoke through him, they responded to the names of demons "Noctumonium, Satemonum Delirium, Gelimer, Mortiferium Fierce and Mortifugo ".

[...]

According to Guerriero, Chiara (the first victim, n.d.r.), in the eyes of the group, represented the Madonna, then Maccione (or daemon through him, to be exact), gave the order to kill (77), while Fabio was killed because he imitated the trances of Maccione (95 -120). According Maccione, however, Fabio and Chiara had spontaneously decided to be killed for sacrifice to Satan (12-15-40).
source

From an interview to the group's "medium", Maccione:

Mario excludes the presence of a higher level in the organization, someone who was giving orders from above:
"It is true that outside there are many satanic cults. But we were alone, we killed each other out."
And the killers who survived, then? Volpe, Sapone, Leoni?
"We are all enemies."
source

share|improve this answer
3  
During the heyday of this nonsesne (I'm in law enforcement) police agencies were subjecting their officers to training on "how to spot signs of Satanic activity"..... –  M. Werner Apr 30 '11 at 14:10

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.